Double-Blind Scholarly Evaluation

Peer Review Process & Workflow

Stage-by-stage peer review procedures, turnaround benchmarks, and decision criteria of Journal of Entrepreneurship, Innovation and Sustainability in the Global Halal Economy.

All submitted manuscripts undergo a rigorous, independent Double-Blind Peer Review process. The identities of both author(s) and reviewer(s) are strictly concealed from each other throughout the evaluation process to guarantee impartiality, scholarly objectivity, and transparency.

Standard Academic Publishing Workflow

Editorial & Peer Review Workflow

International standard manuscript handling workflow from initial submission, independent peer review evaluation, to official publication.

Initial Screening
1–2 Weeks
Peer Review
Typically 3–6 Weeks
Editorial Decision
After reviews received
Author Revision
Per decision letter
Production
Typically 1–2 Weeks
Author Submits Manuscript
Editorial Office Checks Submission
Editor Conducts Initial Screening
Desk Rejection
Manuscript Passes Screening and Is Sent for Peer Review
Independent Peer Review (Double-Blind)
Review Reports Received
Editorial Decision
Accept
Minor or Major Revision
Author Revises and Resubmits
Editorial Assessment / Further Review
Reject
Copyediting and Production
Author Proofreading
DOI and Metadata Verification
Publication on Journal Website
1

1. Initial Desk Screening

Preliminary assessment of manuscript formatting against the official template, alignment with journal scope, and plagiarism screening (Turnitin ≤ 20%). Submissions that fail to meet baseline standards face immediate Desk Rejection.

2

2. Double-Blind Peer Review

Manuscripts are evaluated anonymously by at least two independent expert peer reviewers. Reviewers assess scientific rigor, methodological soundness, originality, and citation relevance.

3

3. Editorial Decision

Editors evaluate reviewer reports to render a formal editorial verdict: Accept, Minor or Major Revision, or Reject. All decisions include comprehensive constructive feedback.

4

4. Author Revision Cycle

Authors address reviewer comments systematically and resubmit their revised manuscript alongside an itemized point-by-point response table. Revised submissions undergo editorial verification.

5

5. Copyediting & Proofreading

Accepted manuscripts undergo professional copyediting, XML/PDF layout typesetting, metadata validation, and final author proofreading prior to publication scheduling.

6

6. Publication & Indexing

Official Crossref DOI assignment and immediate Gold/Diamond Open Access publication on the journal platform, ensuring worldwide discoverability, citation tracking, and indexing.

Reviewer Recommendation Options

  • Accept Submission: Manuscript is accepted without further substantive changes and moves immediately to production.
  • Revisions Required: Minor adjustments requested before formal editorial acceptance; handling editor reviews changes.
  • Resubmit for Review: Substantial theoretical, empirical, or methodological enhancements required; the revised version will undergo a rigorous second round of peer review.
  • Decline Submission: Manuscript lacks sufficient scholarly merit, originality, or novelty for publication in this journal.